Timothy, Here are the reasons why...

1. Linux is designed as a server based network operating system.  Therefore, it give the user an entire
range of server based applications (such as sweeping tools, intrusion systems, streaming music players,
game servers, etc) that would not be acceptable to St John's acceptable use policy.

2. There is no standard antivirus application that is available for Linux based systems that are intended 
for use as desktop devices.  Antivirus software that meets the same security and antivirus protection 
levels currently in place at St John's are designed for Linux devices deployed as servers.  For example, 
The Symantec solution for a Linux server would cost the user appx $600.  Shareware/Freeware antivirus 
solutions for Linux are not adequate protection.

3. An infected Linux laptop, it is a more powerful virus delivery system than a standard Windows based 
system.  This applies to viruses, trojans, and spyware that may infect the system.  Infected Windows 
systems typically hang and shut down.  An infected Linux system can continue to run, attempting to infect 
other devices.

4. The Linux OS does not use (or need) any of the Windows based servers on your network.  The student could 
create a completely separate network on their own.  (For games, music, file sharing, etc)

5. If authorized, they would still be able to use the base resources of the network (such as printing, file 
access, and Internet access) but would have the potential to undermine (even accidentally) the base 
integrity of the network.

Put another way, the school would not allow a student to bring a laptop loaded with Windows 2003 Server or 
Novell.  Linux based devices should be treated the same way.

If you have any other questions please contact the Technology Dept.

Mrs. Coyne





-----Original Message-----
From: Timothy
Sent: Tuesday, November 02, 2004 4:27 PM
To: NATASHA COYNE
Subject: RE: **LAPTOP REGISTRATION**

Why is the school not allowing Unix/Linux based Operating Systems?




-----Original Message-----
From:   NATASHA COYNE
Sent:   Tue 11/2/2004 3:07 PM
To:     YOG2005; YOG2006; YOG2007; YOG2008
Cc:    
Subject:        **LAPTOP REGISTRATION**
To All:

I wanted to inform all of you that laptop registration is still open. (Stop by the Technology Office to 
make an appointment). You can register your laptop at any time throughout the school year BUT you will 
not be able to use your laptop on campus without it being registered. The deadline for registration is Nov. 23rd.

Please note: ONLY Windows and MACINTOSH Operating Systems are allowed. There
               will be NO exceptions to this requirement.

Thank you,
THE TECHNOLOGY DEPT.